Domain 06 · Yang–Mills Existence and Mass Gap
Millennium status, 20 October 2026: Clay continues to list Yang–Mills existence and mass gap as Unsolved. Progress in restricted or regularized settings does not establish both the complete four-dimensional construction and the physical mass gap. Full comparison.
The question in everyday language
Yang–Mills theory provides the mathematical language for important forces in particle physics. Its famous unsolved problem asks for a rigorous construction of the relevant four-dimensional quantum theory and a proof that it has a positive mass gap, a minimum nonzero excitation energy.
GCL has documented the exact claim and analyzed approaches that fall short. Mathematical models on finite lattices, numerical experiments and partial estimates can offer insight, but they do not automatically establish the complete theory.
What remains uncertain: neither the required existence theorem nor the mass-gap theorem has been proved by this programme.
Detailed research record
Accessible research guide: YM-001 Research Guide
Research surface authority
LIVE: YM-001 canonical tracker #164, with active source/proof-completeness returns in MATHSOLVE.
AUTHORITY: YM-WP00-source-normalization-equivalence-audit.md and registered protected campaign records.
EXPOSITION: this page is a human-facing projection. The issue governs mutable research state; protected records govern promoted/certified claims.
Campaign ID: YM-001
Mathematical status: open problem
Programme state: WP00 promoted; WP01 promoted as eliminative infrastructure; WP02 promoted as theorem/dependency interface ledger
Research routing: native MATHSOLVE restricted-target selection open only against YM-D001 through YM-D005
Governance: ADR-0009
Canonical challenge
For every compact simple gauge group, construct a nontrivial four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills theory satisfying an accepted axiomatic floor and prove a strictly positive finite physical mass gap.
Existence and mass gap are separate but jointly required theorem trunks. A fixed lattice model, finite-volume gap, perturbative expansion, numerical spectrum, confinement heuristic, or area-law result does not by itself solve the Clay problem.
Programme posture
YM-WP00 fixes the official statement, Wightman and Osterwalder–Schrader floor, quantifiers, regulator and reconstruction interfaces, gap normalization, exclusion ledger, and formal proposition schemas. It is a promoted source-normalized non-solution artifact.
YM-WP01 supplies a twenty-fixture executable false-proof atlas. YM-WP02 supplies a source-normalized theorem and route ledger with explicit composition states and dependency debt. Their July 2026 package was integrated through PR #115 and passed Programme policy CI. The later MATHFORGE provider audits independently resolved the imported-source locator/scope obligation and the four moving external-source debts YM-D006 through YM-D009.
The post-merge disposition promotes WP01/WP02 only as bounded research infrastructure. YM-D001 through YM-D005 remain open mathematical debts. The current routing gate opens restricted-target selection in grandchallenge/MATHSOLVE only so that one of those debts can be attacked under an exact target contract. Unrestricted mechanism generation, free-standing numerical experimentation, novelty claims, and terminal solution claims remain closed.
A protected 2026-09-18 D003 supplement now admits the Balaban four-dimensional large-field/ultraviolet-stability spine as bounded theorem input and records the Magnen–Rivasseau–Sénéor fixed-infrared-cutoff UV-removal construction with its explicit proof-completeness, IR, topology, and OS limitations. D003 therefore no longer treats 4d large-field control as wholly absent; its live residual frontier is infrared/infinite-volume removal, uniqueness/full continuum identification, complete OS reconstruction, and physical scale identification.
Canonical artifacts
- WP00 integrated audit
- WP01 false-proof atlas
- WP02 theorem and route ledger
- WP01/WP02 integration record
- Post-merge disposition
- Current routing gate
- D003 UV/large-field supplement
- WP00 merge record PR #86
- WP01/WP02 merge record PR #115
- Catalogue-integration decision ADR-0009
Claim boundary
The programme has not constructed four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills theory, proved a physical mass gap, confinement, an area law, regulator-independent continuum control, or a complete Osterwalder–Schrader limiting hierarchy. Promotion of WP01/WP02 changes research routing only; it does not establish that any open dependency debt has been solved.