YM-001 Accessible Research Guide
Research surface authority
LIVE: YM-001 canonical tracker #164, with historical, closed contribution returns MATHSOLVE #716, #717, and #718. These returns are not active child controllers.
AUTHORITY: YM-WP00-source-normalization-equivalence-audit.md and governance/governed_campaign_registry.json.
EXPOSITION: this guide explains protected state; it does not promote or certify mathematics.
1. Status
Yang–Mills existence and mass gap remain open. GCL has a promoted source-normalized baseline, an executable false-proof layer, a theorem/dependency ledger, and bounded source-completeness work. No protected record constructs the full four-dimensional theory or proves the physical mass gap.
2. Plain object
The theorem has two inseparable trunks: construct the interacting four-dimensional continuum theory with the required axiomatic/reconstruction properties, and prove a strictly positive finite spectral gap above the vacuum.
Reader entry and prerequisites
Status: open existence-and-mass-gap target, protected source/theorem interfaces only. Audience: graduate mathematical physics readers, source auditors, and proof-completeness reviewers. Time to first example: 10 minutes. Time to first fixture: 10 minutes.
| Level | Concepts |
|---|---|
| Required | Matrices, eigenvalues, limits of real sequences |
| Helpful | Hilbert spaces, spectra, positive operators |
| Deferred | Gauge fields, constructive QFT, Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction and Slavnov identities |
3. Current obstruction
The present residual is not merely ultraviolet control. Protected work recognizes bounded four-dimensional UV/large-field input, but the route still requires infrared/infinite-volume removal, uniqueness or full continuum identification, complete Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction, and physical scale identification before a mass-gap theorem can be claimed.
4. Working model
Programme state is routed through the exact theorem/dependency obligations rather than broad mechanism generation. The D003 line has been narrowed by source reconstruction and adversarial proof-completeness review; downstream work must state the function-space/topological framework, convergence domain, uniformity, Slavnov-identity passage, and regulator/IR interpretation needed by the intended theorem.
Core bridge and first examples by hand
Friendly example: the finite Hermitian matrix \(H=\mathrm{diag}(0,2)\) has vacuum energy 0 and first excited energy 2. Its finite spectral gap is exactly 2.
Obstruction example: the sequence \(H_n=\mathrm{diag}(0,1/n)\) has a positive gap for each finite \(n\), but the gaps tend to zero. Thus showing positivity at every regulator does not establish a strictly positive limiting physical gap. Neither matrix is a model of the actual four-dimensional Yang–Mills theory.
Bridge: finite spectrum → regulator-dependent gap → absence of uniform lower bound → continuum/OS reconstruction and positive physical gap as separate theorem obligations.
First computation or fixture
Python 3 exact rational toy gap experiment:
from fractions import Fraction
for n in (1, 2, 5, 10):
gap = Fraction(1, n)
print(n, gap)
# Expected: (1,1), (2,1/2), (5,1/5), (10,1/10), printed as separate rows
Input \(n\); operation reads the nonzero eigenvalue of a two-dimensional diagonal matrix; output is exact rational arithmetic. Support route: elementary regression fixture. Limitation: no continuum, interacting QFT or Yang–Mills evidence.
First theorem or local proposition
Vanishing-gap lemma. For \(H_n=\mathrm{diag}(0,1/n)\), every finite \(H_n\) has positive spectral gap but \(\inf_n\mathrm{gap}(H_n)=0\). Proof: for any \(\varepsilon>0\), choose an integer \(n>1/\varepsilon\). This demonstrates why a regulator-independent bound is a separate analytic requirement; it cannot substitute for the full theory existence axioms.
5. Restricted claim
Protected records may be used as bounded source and theorem-interface inputs only. They do not establish Yang–Mills existence, a mass gap, confinement, an area law, or regulator-independent continuum control.
6. Theorem-spine location
Programme authority:
- YM-WP00-source-normalization-equivalence-audit.md
- governance/governed_campaign_registry.json
LIVE coordination: - Programme #164 (canonical campaign mirror; current open-theorem work must be read from the protected Solve handoff) - MATHSOLVE #716–#718 (closed historical D003 contribution returns; not new active work)
7. Debt audit
Open debt includes the full continuum/reconstruction bridge, theorem-grade convergence on the downstream-required domain, uniformity sufficient for a Schwinger hierarchy, preservation of Slavnov identities in the limit, and the physical mass-gap implication.
8. Claim boundary
Issue closure, source discovery, replay, numerical evidence, or this guide cannot create mathematical or certification authority. MATHCERT remains the certification surface.
Challenge ladder
| Stage | Duty | Completion test |
|---|---|---|
| Exercise | Find the eigenvalues of \(H=\mathrm{diag}(0,2)\) | 0 and 2 |
| Exploration | Derive the finite \(H_n\) gaps | \(1/n\) |
| Fixture | Execute rational checker | Match all four values |
| Lemma candidate | Prove vanishing-gap lemma | Quantified \(\varepsilon\) argument |
| Open direction | Trace one D003 theorem-grade convergence dependency | Name topology/domain/uniformity needed by actual downstream statement |
Certification path and continuation graph
The finite-matrix lemma is independently provable but not a YM certificate. Native Solve proof-completeness work must source-lock the actual continuum/OS/Slavnov statements and preserve its function-space, IR, regulator and uniformity conditions before any Cert handoff.
matrix fixture → uniform-gap obstruction → exact D003 source theorem → continuum/OS convergence bridge [OPEN] → physical-spectrum construction → Cert [not yet eligible]
Trust quartet
Proved: elementary vanishing-gap lemma, and only bounded source claims protected by GCL. Checked: rational matrix fixture and closed historical D003 returns. Open: construction, full reconstruction, spectral gap. External verification: convergence and reconstruction in actual primary sources, not the finite toy model.
Bibliography and source audit
| Source | Role | Audit state |
|---|---|---|
| YM WP00 source audit | Canonical Clay target and axiomatic floor | Protected Programme authority |
| D003 UV/large-field supplement | Bounded source context | Protected, not terminal bridge |
| Jaffe–Witten; Osterwalder–Schrader; Balaban / MRS sources (locked in protected ledger) | Imported theorem dependencies | Exact source scope and proof completeness remain controlling |
First executable step / completion test: Reproduce the finite counterexample and identify one actual missing D003 implication with named domain, topology, uniformity estimate and source identity; do not infer a physical mass gap from the toy sequence.
9. First executable step
Read #164, then re-fetch the current protected Solve handoff for the smallest surviving D003 proof-completeness node. Work only against protected source locks and return an exact theorem, falsification, or blocker.