Skip to content

FIGURATE: source-critical bibliography and novelty boundaries

FIGURATE-SRC-001. Documentary edition: 3 November 2026. Status: primary abstract/metadata assertions checked against author, arXiv or publisher pages; proof-level source-semantic and exhaustive novelty reviews remain open. This is an evidence catalogue, not independent mathematical certification.

Controlled mathematical taxonomy

Let the polygonal number of order \(k\) be

\[ P_k(t)=\frac{(k-2)t^2-(k-4)t}{2}. \]

Our Type A studies classical square-output Diophantine tuples whose entries are polygonal; the defining relations are \(a_i=P_k(t_i)\) and \(a_i a_j+n=x_{ij}^2\).

Our Type B studies tuples whose pairwise outputs are polygonal; their relations are \(a_i a_j+c=P_k(t_{ij})\).

Our Type C requires polygonal entries and polygonal pairwise outputs. In each case the entries are distinct positive integers and the order, offset and allowed indices are part of the problem statement. The expression triangular Diophantine tuple has been applied to more than one of these definitions; indexing by the phrase alone causes semantic mistakes.

Source register

Key Primary source Specific source-supported statement Classification and caution
F01 Bagchi and Zhou-Zheng, Diophantine m-tuples of Triangular Numbers, arXiv:2608.27697 (posted 27 August 2026) No all-triangular classical \(D(1)\) quadruple; infinite constructed family of all-triangular \(D(1)\) triples, conjectured complete; no all-triangular \(D(n)\) pair when \(n\) is 2 or 5 mod 9; generalized-Pell test with stated complexity bound. A, triangular. Family completeness is a conjecture, not a theorem. The absence of \(D(1)\) quadruples is not absence of all \(D(n)\) quadruples.
F02 Radić, On some D(u²) triples and quadruples of triangular numbers, arXiv:2609.28018 (posted 23 September 2026) Classifies certain all-triangular \(D(u^2)\) triples with prescribed smallest entry, and constructs all-triangular quadruples for infinitely many positive \(u\). A, triangular with variable square offset. Refutes any overbroad paraphrase extending F01's \(D(1)\) nonexistence to all square offsets.
F03 Filipin, Jurasić and Togbé, A note on the extension of some triangular Diophantine sets, Ann. Sci. Univ. Ovidius Constanţa Ser. Mat. 34(2), July 2026, DOI:10.2478/auom-2026-0018 For the specifically studied triangular \(D(k)\) pairs \(\{k,2k\}\) at \(k=10,28\), no extension to a quadruple. B, triangular outputs. The \(k\) in that paper denotes an offset, not the polygonal order of our \(P_k\). No general nonexistence is inferred.
F04 Filipin and Szalay, Triangular Diophantine tuples from {1, 2}, Rad HAZU Matematičke znanosti 27 (2023), 55–70, DOI:10.21857/ygjwrcp48y No triangular-output \(D(1)\) quadruple containing both 1 and 2. B. For instance, the bounded triple \(\{1,2,27\}\) is not new, and cannot be extended to a quadruple containing these entries.
F05 Jukić Bokun and Soldo, Triangular D(−1)-tuples, Bulletin mathématique de la Société des Sciences Mathématiques de Roumanie 69 (2024), 233–239 Classifies certain triples of form \(\{1,2,c\}\) with a prime-power restriction on \(c\) and proves nonextension of the listed cases. B, offset −1. Restricted shape; do not generalize to all triangular-output tuples. Metadata/abstract in institutional registry, not independently replayed proof.
F06 Rayaguru, Panda and Togbé, On Diophantine, pronic and triangular triples of balancing numbers, Mathematical Communications 25 (2020), 137–155 Defines triangular tuples using unshifted pairwise triangular products and studies balancing-number instances. B, offset 0 with special balancing-number constructions. Offset 0 is legitimate established prior art, not a new FIGURATE definition.
F07 He, Togbé and Ziegler, There is no Diophantine quintuple, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 371 (2019), 6665–6709 Classical \(D(1)\) positive-integer quintuple nonexistence theorem. Classical square-output background. Any new claim about \(D(1)\) quintuples must respect this global result.
F08 Dujella, On the size of Diophantine m-tuples, Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 132 (2002), 23–33 Formal definition of \(D(n)\) and historical context, including Fermat's \(\{1,3,8,120\}\). Classical D(n) background; source abstract partly historical and may predate later resolved conjectures.
F09 Dujella, continuously maintained Diophantine m-tuples bibliography Literature-discovery index, including 2026 triangular-number work and related developments. Index only. A reference list does not itself certify theorem statements or comprehensive novelty.

Chronology and semantic reconciliation

F01 is about triangular entries with square pairwise outputs and offset 1. F02 subsequently shows that all-triangular quadruples do exist for infinitely many other offsets of the form square parameters. These findings are compatible because their offsets differ.

F03 and F04 instead impose triangular pairwise outputs, so their nonextension results apply to Type B rather than to Type A.

F05 covers the negative offset case. F06 already studies unshifted triangular pairwise products. All should be compared before proposing any uniform extension criterion.

In particular, our L60 computational rows with zero quadruples cannot be promoted into global nonexistence, and the positive square-order offset-zero counts mostly expose the elementary fact that products of squares are squares.

Novelty ledger and research targets

Candidate claim or question Status on 3 November 2026 Requirement before promotion
Complete classification of all triangular-entry \(D(1)\) triples F01 conjecture; not a GCL discovery Compare any proposed classification with F01's exact constructed family and hypotheses
All-triangular \(D(1)\) quadruple nonexistence Known theorem F01 No rediscovery claim
All-triangular \(D(u^2)\) quadruple nonexistence for variable \(u\) False in general by F02 Avoid as a programme target
No triangular-output \(D(1)\) quadruple containing 1 and 2 Known theorem F04 No rediscovery claim
Triangular-output \(D(k)\) nonextension for studied \(\{k,2k\}\) at 10 and 28 Known theorem F03 Do not extrapolate without proof
Polygonal-order-uniform modular obstruction for Type B Research direction, no new proof Specify domain, modulus, residue classes, offsets; prove necessity and compare all sources
Parameterized computational sieve and asymptotic cost bound Research direction, no measured speed-up Reproducible implementation and rigorous complexity or verified benchmark comparison
Exhaustive absence within fixed entry bound Finite computation only Exact solver replay, independent witness/coverage check, machine-readable configuration

Full-text source fidelity checkpoint (3 November 2026)

The WP05 theorem matrix now distinguishes inspected original papers from publisher/author abstracts and third-party transcriptions.

The original full text of Filipin and Szalay (2023) was inspected through the journal-hosted PDF. Its Definition 1.2 and Theorem 1.3 prohibit only Type B triangular-output unit-offset quadruples containing the prescribed pair 1 and 2. Lemma 2.1 excludes extension of the known triple with entries 1, 2 and 27; Proposition 6.2 treats large terms of the resulting Pell sequence. The proof uses simultaneous Pell equations, integral-point computations, linear forms in logarithms, recurrence intersections and Baker–Davenport reduction. Reading those dependencies is not an independent verification of Magma or numerical calculations.

Crucially, the same original paper explicitly reports the Type B unit-offset triangular quadruple with entries 14, 31, 135 and 3510. The six pairwise shifted products are triangular numbers of indices 29, 61, 313, 91, 466 and 973. A small entry-bound-60 census cannot see this known witness; no global Type B quadruple absence should be inferred from that census.

The 2025 paper by Filipin, Jurasić and Szalay DOI 10.1515/ms-2025-0057 establishes nonextension of the prescribed triangular-output offset-3 pair with entries 3 and 6, according to its institutional abstract. The original complete proof is not yet inspected.

The 2026 Filipin–Jurasić–Togbé paper has a publisher-confirmed abstract. An accessible third-party reproduction identifies Theorem 1.1 and numbered dependencies Lemma 4.1, Lemma 5.2, Theorem 6.1 and Proposition 6.2, including the final finite Pari/GP reduction. These provisional numbers and details must still be checked against the original publisher PDF. Neither 2026 arXiv paper's original full proof has yet been inspected. No source-fidelity record should be promoted to full-proof review until the missing originals are obtained.

Original primary-manuscript recovery (4 November 2026)

This section supersedes any older blanket description of the 2026 papers as abstract-only evidence. Three original full manuscripts were retrieved and source-locked:

Source Original primary manuscript and SHA-256 Inspected theorems and scope
Bagchi and Zhou-Zheng (2026) arXiv:2608.27697v1 PDF, SHA-256 ce563a160ac5597ea3c5d3461188182e5fdb8727ef45d759227151dd722dd4fd Proposition 3: no Type A triangular-entry classical \(D(1)\) quadruple, by adjoining 8 and invoking the no-quintuple theorem. Propositions 2 and 4: infinite pairs and triples. Theorem 6: triple-generating operation; its claimed completeness remains conjectural. Theorem 8: constrained generalized-Pell correspondence. Theorem 11: Type A offset exclusions modulo 9. Conjecture 12 and Theorem 13: further offset and local-solubility boundaries.
Radić (2026) arXiv:2609.28018v1 PDF, SHA-256 2fc1371a2bbf59ce58515015cbabc05f918c6ebd10eea10304c9a4c1517a6df4 Proposition 1.2: no Type A triangular-entry \(D(4)\) quadruple. Theorem 2.3: recurrence classification of \(D(u^2)\) triples when the smallest triangular index equals \(4u-1\) or \(4u\). Theorem 3.3: obstruction to regular triangular triples when the offset is 2 modulo 3. Proposition 4.1: parameterized construction criterion using a Pell equation. Theorem 1.3: infinite square-offset quadruple construction.
Filipin, Jurasić and Togbé (2026) Original journal PDF, SHA-256 214272aa3cfc9165b87ddc9ab0b2340ebfa738ca3ba48834505f177873e84b67 Theorem 1.1: prescribed Type B triangular-output \(D(k)\) pair with entries \(k,2k\) does not extend to a quadruple for offsets \(k=10,28\). Lemma 3.1: fundamental Pell solutions; Lemma 4.1 and Lemmas 5.1–5.2: logarithmic forms and recurrence-index constraints; Theorem 6.1: Baker–Wüstholz bound; Proposition 6.2: no extension for third entry at least \(1.57\times10^{43}\), followed by the paper's stated Pari/GP reduction for the finite remainder.

Reading a full primary proof to map its dependencies does not independently certify the proofs or replay third-party computer algebra.

Single original-text gap: Filipin, Jurasić and Szalay, Extensions of the triangular D(3)-pair {3,6}, Mathematica Slovaca (2025), DOI 10.1515/ms-2025-0057. The authors' original 2025 presentation supplies a detailed proof outline, but the publisher's complete journal PDF was not obtainable using the available non-circumventing retrieval methods. Its theorem numbering and computational dependencies cannot be reported as independently reconciled to the original journal text. Accordingly, the literal WP05 full-original acceptance criterion remains OPEN.

The versioned WP05 recovery matrix records manuscript checksums, version distinctions, theorem/proof dependencies, a competing forthcoming pair-extension paper, and precise open evidence. Avoid promoting WP05 to complete until that final original paper is examined.

Source audit method and limitations

The register verifies publication identities, terminology and narrow theorem conclusions. The original 2023 journal paper and three primary papers recovered in November 2026 have undergone source-reading and theorem-dependency extraction. The original 2025 Mathematica Slovaca journal text remains unavailable for reconciliation against author slides. None of these source readings independently certifies the authors' proofs or computational appendices, and no literature search proves exhaustive originality. Treat the F01 completeness conjecture as apparently open in the inspected 2026 sources, rather than a claim about all possible unpublished work.

On any new theorem submission, freeze source versions, inspect full primary proofs, record theorem numbers, compare exact parameter domains, and submit the novelty and claim-semantics assessment to the appropriate mathematical adjudication lane. This catalogue is enough to prevent the important known misclassifications; it is not a mathematical originality certificate.

Continuity

Parent: FIGURATE-PILOT-001. Method and finite evidence: MATHSOLVE census archive. Reader introduction: FIGURATE primer. Documentary bibliography complete at registered-primary-source level; proof-level semantic verification and future novelty assessment remain open research controls.