Documentary state: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. This draft has NOT been editorially admitted. Mathematical claims require independent checking.
OAI-26 family 100: a claimed counterexample to Bang's cylinder-covering bound
Editorial status: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. NO_CERTIFICATION. The statements below are attributed to the pinned publisher overview; the four underlying proof manuscripts have not undergone independent GCL theorem-level audit.
The question in plain language
How little cross-sectional area can a finite collection of infinitely extended cylinders use to cover a three-dimensional solid? A cylinder here means a set swept out along a fixed direction from a perpendicular planar base—not necessarily a circular tube. Bang's proposed half-area covering bound says, roughly, that a covering should cost at least half a relevant projected area of the solid.
Family 100 reports a construction that beats this benchmark even when the solid is a regular tetrahedron and the cylinder bases are compact triangles.
A small example
Imagine shining a light on a tetrahedron. Its orthogonal shadow on a perpendicular plane has a certain area, and the area depends on the viewing direction. A cylinder with that direction has a planar perpendicular cross-section; extending the cross-section along a line yields a three-dimensional set. Several such cylinders, potentially pointing in different directions, may jointly cover the tetrahedron.
The quantity at issue is the sum of the areas of the individual perpendicular bases, not the volume of the infinitely long cylinders, nor the area of their union in one common plane. The claimed construction uses finitely many cylinders and covers the entire closed regular tetrahedron, including the boundary.
What is known
The protected Family 100 catalogue names four manuscripts: finite angular covers, finite approximation of ruled sets, slope-field perturbations of a two-cylinder covering, and triangular approximation of radial sweeps.
The pinned publisher overview claims a finite covering of a closed regular tetrahedron \(T\) by cylinders \(C_1,\ldots,C_N\) with compact triangular bases \(B_1,\ldots,B_N\) satisfying
This formula expresses the overview's stated claim, not a independently established mathematical fact. On its face, it is stronger than merely beating half the projected area in one chosen direction: the right side is half the smallest projection area across all directions.
According to that overview, the construction disproves both Bang's half-area cylinder-covering conjecture and a stronger directionwise-normalized conjecture in dimension three. The exact formulations of both conjectures must be checked against the manuscripts before interpreting the purported counterexample.
GCL verification state
The source lock is openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. The pinned source overview explicitly attributes the finite covering and strict inequality to Family 100. All four manuscript identities and their repository paths are recorded by the GCL catalogue.
This documentary pass has not verified the explicit cylinder parameters, whether each perpendicular base is indeed triangular and compact, the treatment of the tetrahedron boundary, the strict numerical area gap, or the claimed implications for the competing conjecture formulations. No Family 100-specific Lean elaboration, Comparator replay, independent critical proof audit, or MATHCERT certificate is asserted.
What remains
Read the four pinned PDFs and reconstruct the covering scheme. Check that finitely many cylinders suffice without an uncovered boundary or limiting residual set; distinguish finite approximations from limiting ruled-surface constructions. Extract all direction vectors, triangle coordinates, and base-area estimates.
Verify the minimum tetrahedron projection area with the normalization used by the manuscripts. Recompute the strict inequality from auditable exact or interval-arithmetic bounds, and establish that the bound applies to the correct covering model. Examine the logical relationship between Bang's original half-area conjecture and the directionwise-normalized formulation rather than treating the two as identical.
Run documentary validation and MkDocs rendering checks, conduct source-critical review, and complete protected merge/readback. None of those editorial actions alone certifies the underlying counterexample.
Sources and claim boundaries
- Finite angular cylinder covers below the half area bound.
- Finite cylinder approximation of ruled sets.
- Slope field perturbations of the two cylinder covering.
- Finite triangular approximation of radial sweeps.
- Pinned publisher overview, Family 100.
- GCL editorial assignment.
Boundary: NO_CERTIFICATION. The counterexample and stated consequences remain publisher-reported claims pending independent mathematical verification.
Indexed primary manuscript paths:
- Finite angular cylinder covers below the half-area bound —
preprints/Finite-angular-cylinder-covers-below-the-half-area-bound-September-27-2026/main.pdf - Finite cylinder approximation of ruled sets —
preprints/Finite-cylinder-approximation-of-ruled-sets-September-27-2026/main.pdf - Slope-field perturbations of the two-cylinder covering —
preprints/Slope-field-perturbations-of-the-two-cylinder-covering-September-27-2026/main.pdf - Finite triangular approximation of radial sweeps —
preprints/Finite-triangular-approximation-of-radial-sweeps-September-27-2026/main.pdf