Skip to content

Documentary state: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. This draft has NOT been editorially admitted. Mathematical claims require independent checking.

OAI-26 family 088: projection-body inequalities and simplex counterexamples

Editorial status: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. NO_CERTIFICATION. This article explains claims indexed in two pinned manuscripts, without independently verifying their proofs.

The question in plain language

A convex body has a volume, and it casts shadows—orthogonal projections—whose sizes vary with direction. A projection body packages the volumes of those shadows into a new convex body. Projection-body inequalities compare the size and shape of the original body with the size of this derived object.

The pinned OAI-26 overview reports two contrasting conclusions. It claims that ellipsoids minimize projection-body volume among convex bodies of fixed volume in dimensions at least four, while products of simplices defeat a conjectured simplex-based maximum for a normalized projection-body volume.

A small example

Imagine a three-dimensional convex solid and measure the areas of its shadows from every direction. Those measurements describe its projection body. In \(n\) dimensions the relevant shadows have dimension \(n-1\).

One can ask two separate optimization questions: Which body has the smallest projection-body volume when its own volume is fixed? Which body has the largest normalized projection-body volume? Answers to the minimum problem do not determine the maximum.

An ellipsoid is an affine image of a Euclidean ball. A simplex is the higher-dimensional analogue of a triangle or tetrahedron. A product of simplices is generally not itself a simplex, and its projection behavior may differ substantially.

What is known

The protected catalogue identifies two Family 088 manuscripts, both dated September 24, 2026: Petty's projection-volume conjecture in dimensions at least four and A product counterexample to the simplex maximum for projection-body volume.

The pinned publisher overview claims that in every dimension \(n\ge4\), ellipsoids uniquely minimize projection-body volume at a fixed volume of the original convex body. It also reports the full Lutwak–Petty projection inequalities. The exact normalization and interpretation of uniqueness up to affine transformations require inspection of the paper.

By contrast, the second manuscript reportedly constructs products of simplices that exceed Brannen's proposed simplex maximum for normalized projection-body volume by an exponential factor in every sufficiently large dimension.

The two statements address different extremal directions. The second is a counterexample to a proposed maximum, not a contradiction of the minimum theorem. Nor does a counterexample in all sufficiently large dimensions imply one in every dimension.

GCL verification state

The source snapshot is openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. The protected catalogue contains both manuscripts, and the pinned overview supplies their respective claims.

This editorial pass has not independently reproduced the projection-body calculations, checked sharp constants, or verified the asserted exponential separation. No Family 088-specific Lean theorem, Comparator result, proof-semantic audit, or MATHCERT certificate is established.

What remains

Read both pinned manuscripts and identify the precise definitions of projection bodies and normalized volume. For the minimum result, check the admissible convex-body class, positivity and regularity assumptions, dimension range, uniqueness conditions, and how the Lutwak–Petty inequalities are derived.

For the simplex counterexample, inspect the products used, calculate the normalized projection-body volume and verify the asymptotic exponential comparison, including the threshold on dimension. Keep the minimum theorem separate from the disputed maximum prediction.

Complete mathematical Markdown and rendered-compendium validation, source-bound editorial criticism, and protected merge/readback. Documentary admission does not amount to proof certification.

Sources and claim boundaries

Boundary: NO_CERTIFICATION. These are publisher-reported claims rather than independently certified results.


Indexed primary manuscript paths: