Documentary state: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. This draft has NOT been editorially admitted. Mathematical claims require independent checking.
OAI-26 family 046: counterexamples to Shafarevich holomorphic convexity
Editorial status: DRAFT_UNACCEPTED. NO_CERTIFICATION. This article describes two publisher-indexed constructions; it does not independently verify their proofs.
The question in plain language
A complex projective variety may have an infinite universal covering space. Shafarevich's holomorphic-convexity question asks whether universal covers of certain projective varieties must have a strong complex-analytic finiteness property called holomorphic convexity. A stronger property, being Stein, supplies abundant holomorphic functions and has particularly useful analytic consequences.
The pinned OAI-26 overview reports counterexamples. It describes both a complex surface refuting an unrestricted holomorphic-convexity assertion and a projective fourfold with a large fundamental group whose universal cover has no positive-dimensional compact analytic subvarieties but is neither Stein nor holomorphically convex.
A small example
For an ordinary Euclidean space, an infinite sequence escaping every compact set can be detected by coordinate functions growing large along a suitable subsequence. Holomorphic convexity makes an analogous demand using holomorphic functions, but on a general complex space such functions may be too scarce to detect all escaping sequences.
A Stein manifold is holomorphically convex, but the converse need not hold in general. Consequently, non-Stein alone does not establish non-holomorphic-convexity. The publisher's fourfold claim is stronger because it asserts both failures separately.
Likewise, having no compact analytic subvarieties of positive dimension does not by itself imply Steinness. The proposed construction is intended to separate these two features.
What is known
The protected Family 046 catalogue lists two source manuscripts:
- A projective fourfold with large fundamental group and non-Stein universal cover (October 5, 2026).
- A surface counterexample to Shafarevich holomorphic convexity (September 23, 2026).
The publisher overview reports a smooth projective complex fourfold with large fundamental group whose universal cover contains no positive-dimensional compact analytic subvariety, while failing both Steinness and holomorphic convexity. It additionally reports an independent smooth projective complex surface counterexample to the unrestricted Shafarevich holomorphic-convexity claim.
The word unrestricted is significant. An example that disproves a conjecture without auxiliary hypotheses need not contradict a stronger or modified theorem incorporating additional assumptions. The exact definition of “large fundamental group,” the covering-space structure, and the relation of the two constructions require direct examination of the PDFs.
GCL verification state
The indexed source snapshot is openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. The Family 046 catalogue records both manuscripts and the overview supplies their claimed scope.
This documentary pass has not independently validated the geometry of either construction, computed the universal-cover properties, or checked the claimed absence of compact positive-dimensional analytic subspaces. No specific Family 046 Lean theorem, Comparator replay, semantic proof equivalence, or MATHCERT certification has been established.
What remains
A source critic should read both pinned papers, record their exact principal theorems and constructions, and verify smoothness, projectivity, dimension, and the nature of their fundamental groups. For the fourfold, independently distinguish the arguments for non-Steinness, non-holomorphic-convexity, and the absence of positive-dimensional compact analytic subvarieties. For the surface, inspect the precise form of the Shafarevich statement disproved.
Review should also determine whether these examples depend on particular field or covering assumptions not mentioned in the synopsis. Subsequently validate mathematical Markdown and rendered HTML, obtain source-bound editorial criticism, and perform protected merge/readback. Documentary admission is not proof certification.
Sources and claim boundaries
- Pinned projective fourfold manuscript.
- Pinned surface counterexample manuscript.
- Pinned OAI-26 overview, Family 046.
- GCL editorial issue.
Boundary: NO_CERTIFICATION. These are reported counterexamples, not independently verified constructions or certified mathematical conclusions.
Indexed primary manuscript paths:
- A projective fourfold with large fundamental group and non-Stein universal cover —
preprints/A-projective-fourfold-with-large-fundamental-group-and-non-Stein-universal-cover-October-5-2026/large-fundamental-group-non-stein.pdf - A surface counterexample to Shafarevich holomorphic convexity —
preprints/A-surface-counterexample-to-Shafarevich-holomorphic-convexity-September-23-2026/paper.pdf