Source-integrity exception adjudication; exact live 46-case inventory (2026-10-21)
This is a bounded, role-separated source-semantic handoff, not source correction admission or proof certification. It preserves the original RESULT/1, GCL-RETURN-EXCEPTION/1 and competing worker claims. A literal search for GCL-RETURN-EXCEPTION/1 among OPEN issue comments was reconciled by fetching all issue comments for the 46 matches. Search membership is not in itself a mathematical verdict. The original October 19 snapshot of 40 invalid-only issues is a distinct, earlier cohort and must not be equated to the current 46.
Counted source roster
- Live issues with one exception request: 46 (46 original exception comments; observed).
- Six issues with one RESULT/1 each: #1846, #1828, #1896, #1842, #1819, #1827.
- Forty issues with two RESULT/1 comments each, thus requiring competing-return identity and compatibility review: #2089, #2087, #2086, #2090, #2088, #2113, #2093, #2116, #2114, #2104, #2094, #2121, #2111, #2095, #2106, #2091, #2099, #2092, #2083, #2115, #2102, #2097, #2122, #2105, #2101, #2120, #2084, #2118, #2117, #2109, #2108, #2107, #2103, #2100, #2096, #2110, #2098, #2119, #2085, #2112.
- Three exact-case mathematical review records: #1846 / Erdős 575, #1842 / Erdős 571, #1827 / Erdős 556.
- 43 remain without a GCL-SOURCE-SEMANTIC-REVIEW/1 disposition in this inventory; absence of that marker does not rule out other protected adjudications. Recheck before processing each item.
- Neither the three reviewed claims nor the forty dual-return pairs are declared source-corrected or mathematically certified.
Protected Council source-correction proposal; three cases
- Erdős 575 (#1846): elementary literal noninduced forbidden-family counterexample accepted at verifier level; upstream OPEN / archived DISPROVED status divergence is unresolved. Council must inspect the original and revised domain and source history before adjusting any source metadata. Distinguish exclusion of forests as a revised statement.
- Erdős 571 (#1842): the C4 extremal exponent 3/2 follows by common-neighbor counting and finite projective-plane incidence constructions. Does not settle every rational exponent with a single forbidden bipartite graph. Current OPEN / pinned PROVED source identity discrepancy requires historical source examination.
- Erdős 556 (#1827): under a literal all n>=3 reading, R_3(C3)=17 contradicts 4n-3 at n=3. Intended threshold n>=4 or eventual-n variant requires original Bondy–Erdős domain verification; do not declare the intended problem solved or disproved.
For each: source-specialist may propose SOURCE_CORRECTION_ACCEPTED only after source-era statement locks, full historical and maintained primary-source comparison, adversarial variant review, and a protected Council source-repair receipt. Until then retain original open issue, RETURNED result custody, exception markers and any existing labels. No direct issue-status or Project status mutation is authorized by this dossier.
Remaining review actions
- Six single-return cases: after the three reviewed, assess #1828, #1896, #1819 against their exact comments and cited theorem scope; inspect archived/current source-status disagreements and distinguish strong known partial results from universal claims.
- Forty dual-return cases: collect both exact comment IDs, bodies and hashes; review source validity and mathematical scopes side-by-side; distinguish complementary evidence, conflicting results, and mere reformatted duplicates. Never select the first/newest by default. For each genuine contest, populate the existing protected
governance/erdos_catalogue/RETURN_ARBITRATIONS.jsonand its comparative-review evidence; retain both originals and require source-protection admission before projection. - Persist role-separated VERIFIER, ADVERSARY and REFEREE findings, negative controls, original attribution and no-certification boundaries. Only accepted source corrections can be routed through existing Council Clerk authority; this handoff itself is not a Council resolution.
Exact observation and governance boundary
Project #2 audit returned 1,327 items and zero semantic field discrepancies at check time. That reports queue consistency only, not substantive source disposition. Status labels are not to be changed merely because this dossier is merged. Repo main source head at authoring: 37384b473239aee26fb6cbefde1b020f06b375fc.