Skip to content

ED09 historical mathematical typography: source-preserving successor route

Control: MP-MATH-TYPO-ED09; original issue #1264.
Baseline: protected MATH-PROGRAMME commit d7c727625858cef20c006a8e1d32580957fde192 (2026-10-25 UTC).
Disposition: Read-only triage complete; this record defines a bounded successor-publication route, not the publication of six successors or amendment of their sources.

Exact source custody and observations

The source scanner identified precisely 256 warnings, all in Markdown authoring context. They are compatibility signals, not 256 invalid mathematical assertions.

Source record (relative to repository root) Exact blob SHA-1 Inline delimiters Display delimiters Operator warnings Total
campaigns/birch_swinnerton_dyer/WP00_FOUNDATION_STATUS/04_SOURCE_NORMALIZATION_EQUIVALENCE_AUDIT.md ff98c1e9bcaa09a1f91a8032f85bec615fce391f 58 17 10 85
campaigns/birch_swinnerton_dyer/WP00_FOUNDATION_STATUS/00_README.md 2dc1d41f67fd72857b03139aacb97e5d47ade604 29 4 6 39
YM-WP00-source-normalization-equivalence-audit.md df360a4295f8545a5665630117c005f18b60fd08 42 10 3 55
research/vgse-eng-wp06/IDENTIFIABILITY_PROOF.md eb1f4b3ffe1810c43873fac0e6ab42d2ae49d2d5 9 17 3 29
records/CMDG_GRAND_CHALLENGE_PROGRAMME_MEMORIAL.md 5131d206f4f14ee027aae1154cda5d6469d674a7 5 22 0 27
campaigns/birch_swinnerton_dyer/WP04_RESTRICTED_TARGET_SCORECARD/00_README.md 76fc8b6e6aa21be1d861f3b462c2e0f55fa99a60 17 1 3 21
Totals 160 71 25 256

The six files are outside the MkDocs public docs tree. The current published MkDocs renderer therefore has no direct page for these six original paths; public MkDocs validation of a future derivative is a separate acceptance test, not a retroactive claim about its original.

A genuine immutable-SHA Chromium 156 browser replay loaded six GitHub original-file views: six HTTP 200 responses, zero page JavaScript errors and zero MathML elements observed. This corroborates GitHub mathematical-visibility debt rather than any false theorem or source-identity change. Retained evidence: CHAD /home/jim/GCL/ED09/evidence/ed09-six-original-github-browser-d7c7276.json; SHA-256 3655b17b44232cbf1ca4058399c463cb23068fea655b199a22dd0c5e2700ef81; authenticated operation capture execution-captures/b96fcd76e71b4fc4ab635e4c95ffedfd.json. Screenshots for representative BSD WP00, Yang–Mills WP00 and CMDG memorial views are retained beside the report. No historical source file was changed.

Classification and authority boundaries

  1. BSD WP00 source audit and foundation record: Promoted normalization and provenance work. Preserve rank, Tate–Shafarevich, leading-term and imported-theorem distinctions; the universal BSD conjecture remains open. Use a derived reader, not an amended WP00 promotion record.
  2. Yang–Mills WP00 source audit: Versioned, source-normalized non-solution dossier. Preserve its source hierarchy, axiom scope, and absence of a claimed quantum Yang–Mills construction or physical mass-gap proof.
  3. VGSE WP06 identifiability proof: Substantive mathematical argument with a five-dimensional boundary-rescaling symmetry and an explicit TE3 qualification. Its C05 adjudication is not editable as a typography fix. Any altered inference requires specialist semantic review and appropriate MATHCERT replay.
  4. CMDG programme memorial: Human-Steward-approved historical motivating architecture, explicitly subordinate to later protected Council decisions. No silent changes to Sections I–XIX; any conceptual divergence requires a separately admitted, linked delta.
  5. BSD WP04 target scorecard: Referee-selected, still-unproved restricted two-primary target. Preserve exact hypotheses, target normalization, selected status and closed mechanism-generation boundary.

No source-audit warning constitutes permission to change a mathematical claim, a result state, a historical authority record or a citation.

Authorized non-destructive successor mechanism

Eligible material: A new source-linked, explicitly derivative mathematical reader or a non-mutating rendering overlay. Each derivative is added only at a distinct new path under docs/historical_math_readers/ in an ordinary branch and protected pull request. The six pinned source paths and their Git blob identities are never overwritten, moved, reformatted or replaced by this workflow.

Each derived reader must contain:

  • A visible DERIVATIVE READING EDITION; NOT AUTHORITATIVE SOURCE notice, original repository path, exact original blob SHA-1, protected baseline commit and source permalink.
  • An explicit source-line-to-derived-location map for every affected formula and any editorial transformations; copy only faithful source material, not new mathematical interpretations.
  • A formula-body preservation manifest. Delimiter changes for GitHub/MkDocs compatibility may be mechanical; operator-macro substitutions require separate verified equivalence. If meaning, hypotheses, quantifiers, source attribution or theorem status changes, this routine editorial route stops and hands off to substantive specialist review; it does not silently promote the change.
  • A link back to the immutable primary record. For the CMDG memorial, a separate delta/concordance rather than a revised memorial; for VGSE, an identified semantic reviewer is required for any mathematical adjudication change.
  • Retention of the original versioned record. No automatic migration of downstream authority references to the derived reader.

Admission: Verify the source hash and a deterministic source/reader correspondence before any candidate commit. Apply the ordinary GCL Markdown math preflight, affected generator/unit tests, strict MkDocs build and rendered validator. Perform actual Chromium GitHub and published/built MkDocs mathematical visibility tests on the derived path; check line-level glyph, displayed and inline math, tables and headings, and retain screenshots or machine-readable browser evidence. Treat original GitHub raw rendering as a known historical exception, not an acceptance target to mutate into correctness. Require normal protected CI/merge-queue governance and exact-main readback; neither worker return nor passed CI is mathematical certification.

Queue authority: MATHSOLVE's protected WORKERS.md recognizes ED09 as an Editorial source-audit task using MATH-PROGRAMME direct_editorial and issue-bound RESULT/1, without /claim. The global Project #2 AVAILABLE view is controlled by the actual gcl-state:available label; the legacy GCL State Project field has no usable options. Queue Class is Editorial, not Mathematics. The separate Project Status must be reconciled with live custody and read back before another worker pickup. This protected route document alone does not mark a worker available, transfer a reservation, start an editor, approve any future derivative PR, or expand authority.

Terminal boundaries

This ED09 triage-and-route record permits source-preserving successor proposals but does not create six corrected editions. If derivative publication is later undertaken, it must be a distinctly tracked bounded editorial operation with its own protected candidate and readback; no historical file may be rewritten. ED09's original read-only source classification may be marked complete once this record is protected-admitted, with the remaining optional derived-publication work explicitly outside the scope of that completion.

The six records' original mathematical meaning, citations, proof status, promotion claims, protected provenance and historical order are unchanged.