Skip to content

Delegated material admission — bounded agent-reviewed profiles

Control: GCL-DELEGATED-MATERIAL-ADMISSION-001
Programme tracking: issue #1247
Governing staffing: effective GI-STEWARD-0003 and MP-STREAMLINED-EXECUTION-001.

What is implemented

A profile-based, fail-closed mechanical reviewer replaces the earlier one-off six-line image deletion exception. Only a protected controller running source from main may classify a pull request and submit an App review. The candidate cannot change its own profile registry or reviewer program and then obtain automatic admission: every eligible candidate must modify exactly one already existing top-level docs/*.md file, and must be internal to MATH-PROGRAMME.

The initial profiles are deliberately narrow:

Profile Exact permitted byte operation
DOC-FINAL-NEWLINE-001 Append one missing terminal LF
DOC-TRAILING-SPACE-001 Remove up to 12 single trailing spaces on non-control narrative lines, never Markdown's double-space hard line break
DOC-REDUNDANT-BLANKS-001 Collapse runs of three or more blank lines without changing any content-bearing line (maximum 12 removed lines)

The classifier rejects fenced code, display mathematics, embedded HTML, front matter, CRLF and tabs, excessive size, source-path traversal, mixed edits, renames, and files outside the exact admitted scope. Existing mathematical claims are not independently judged, and no PR claiming scientific certification is made true by formatting.

Evidence and authority

The protected reviewer reads the old and new file bytes from pinned GitHub commit identities and verifies the head blob SHA against the changed-file record. It computes content hashes and emits a structured exact-head GitHub review. The Verifier and Adversary entries are explicit role-scoped logical audit passes in a single protected system, never falsely claimed to be external, separate runtime sessions, or independent mathematical reviews.

GitHub's one-approval rule, required exact-head validation statuses, current reviewer identity, and the native GH-OS merge queue remain mandatory. The App review is an operational permission for precisely this bounded routine classification, not a general mathematical, security, constitutional, promotion, or certification authority.

A missing/unrecognized profile, missing status, failed semantic exclusion, stale head, mutated base, insufficient metadata or missing review evidence fails closed. A failed attempt must not result in APPROVED; the target PR can still follow its appropriate specialist review and protected merge.

Rollout boundary and successor

The initial registry represents a limited positive proof of agency: the protected controller can perform future bounded housekeeping under three reviewed content transformations, without a repeated human approval. It does not authorize unbounded documentation rewrites, Lean theorem changes, governance-record edits, required-check modifications or release promotion.

The successor under #1247 is a separately governed GCL-AGENT-ADMISSION-SPECIALIST-001 control: independent material-class checks that enforce required specialist evidence on the precise merge candidate, even where someone provides a GitHub approval. Such a check must be shown to work on both pull_request_target and merge_group before adding it to a protected ruleset. Do not mutate a ruleset or the separate GH-OS routing controller under the cover of routine admission.

Operating measurement

Record protected runs, ineligible/fail-closed dispositions, approved exact heads, merged queue heads, failed checks, and human interventions. Guard against a reversion to per-commit Steward review; also guard against false negative classifications being misinterpreted as specialist approval.

Terminal acceptance: protected merge of classifier/profile code and test registry, successful CI including hostile tests, then a live future positive PR through the App and native queue, and a live negative out-of-scope PR. Only then may the broader routine profile tranche be reported as operational.