CMDG CM4 — targeted independent-specialist review execution
Operation: CMDG-CM4-EXTERNAL-REVIEW-OUTREACH-001. Status: REVIEWER SHORTLIST AND HANDOFF READY; NO OUTREACH SENT, NO REVIEW ACCEPTED. The external mathematical disposition remains open exclusively at MATH-PROGRAMME #1222.
Scope and independence
Request an independent mathematical appraisal, not an administrative approval or a check that Lean reports success. CM4 is internally protected-closed; the review addresses mathematical soundness, semantic match to integer-coefficient free solid condensed groups, proof noncircularity and suitability for a human-supervised upstream port. It does not reopen ordinary GCL internal work or make CM5 dependent on a reviewer.
The existing canonical materials already suffice for a first approach:
- External mathematical review packet.
- Standalone mathematical note.
- Reproducibility protocol.
- Exact terminal Lean wrapper.
- External review issue #1222.
Frozen replay checkout: 7a0f33588aa8d1add4d941c9b4681b6910644bf1; terminal source blob 8ab0051746507099f7321460fe091e56a84b57bb, proof module blob d3ef22a2ad2d9c0af6982773d0a24b715e61f5a7; Lean v4.33.0-rc1, mathlib 79d0395a1825a6264ad5d269e35e60537518955e. Reproducing the theorem is not a review disposition.
Publicly identified potential reviewers
This is a candidate contact list, not endorsement or agreement. Confirm current availability, conflicts and appropriate contact method before an approach.
| Candidate | Domain-specific fit | Public evidence | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dagur Ásgeirsson | Formalized condensed mathematics and solid modules; thesis Towards a formalized theory of solid modules, Nöbeling in Lean; source author of mathlib's Solid.lean |
Professional page | Strong fit for semantic comparison but disclose authorship of the upstream interface; independent of GCL proof only if confirmed |
| Johan Commelin | Condensed mathematics formalization and Liquid Tensor Experiment, Mathlib Initiative | Professional page | Confirm independence from any GCL proof production and suitable scope |
| Riccardo Brasca | Formal condensed mathematics, Lean/mathlib maintainer, Liquid Tensor Experiment contributor | Professional page | Confirm no conflict and whether a mathematical rather than solely implementation review is available |
Sequence: contact one qualified candidate with a bounded review brief and a reasonable offer of compensated consulting if appropriate; approach another only on nonresponse or declined scope. Do not solicit blanket endorsement or mass-email multiple researchers. An upstream mathlib maintainer could advise on portability, but that discussion is not itself independent peer review of this proof.
Minimal proposed review commission
Requested result: a dated, attributable, written referee report answering:
- Does the terminal Lean statement correspond to the intended module-level integer-coefficient solidity result, with all universe and category qualifications?
- Is the Point-functional argument noncircular at its five critical proof joints (zero reflection, weighted reconstruction, kernel annihilation, scalar-to-morphism faithfulness, terminal solidity)?
- Does the proof rely on additional substantive assumptions beyond the recorded
[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]footprint or on a semantically inappropriate definition? - Can the reviewer reproduce the pinned theorem, or otherwise identify exactly which part could not be independently checked?
- What is the smallest repair or caveat needed, if any?
Require the referee to choose exactly one disposition from #1222: MATHEMATICALLY_SOUND__UPSTREAM_PORT_JUSTIFIED, SOUND_WITH_REQUIRED_CLARIFICATIONS, GAP_FOUND, TARGET_MISIDENTIFIED, or REVIEW_INCONCLUSIVE. Record specific mathematical reasoning, file/lemma locators, reproducibility identity, reviewer's stated independence, date and permission to preserve the report.
Reviewer-facing first contact (candidate wording)
We have a Lean-checked, source-pinned proof of the module-level integer-coefficient solidity of the free solid condensed module on a profinite set. It uses an underived Point-functional route, rather than the standard derived-Hom argument. Would you be interested in undertaking a bounded independent mathematical review of its semantic match and five critical proof joints, potentially as a paid consultancy? The mathematical note, reproducibility protocol and exact theorem sources are publicly available at the links above. We do not seek endorsement based on compilation alone and would welcome a precise critical finding or an inconclusive report. We can supply a concise review remit and agree on scope before work begins.
Communication boundary: this text has not been sent. GCL must establish an appropriate sender, consent to any commercial terms, and a direct legitimate communication channel before solicitation. No GCL account or identity should represent a reviewer as retained until acceptance is recorded.
Upstream-specific guard
Mathlib's current contribution policy requires human understanding and supervision of AI-assisted work, disclosure of AI use, and expressly disallows LLM-written GitHub/Zulip comments. A GCL agent must not submit an AI-authored mathlib comment/PR or treat this document as upstream permission. The human-supervised upstream-port issue remains #1223; it is separable from #1222.
State and next transition
Current state: REVIEWER_SHORTLIST_READY__NO_CONTACT. The next external step is actual respectful one-to-one solicitation through an authorized sender; then preserve invitation/response, reviewer independence, the exact frozen material and written returned disposition on #1222. Do not mark the review closed because of internal documentation, PR merge, formal replay, or a candidate's general expertise.